Summary
The committee favorably reported NLRB nominees Jim Macy and David Prouty, BLS nominee Brett Matsumoto, and NEH nominee Michael McDonald to the Senate.
Bill Cassidy said Macy would clear the NLRB backlog, Matsumoto would fix flawed jobs data, and McDonald would combat campus antisemitism.
Bill Cassidy conditioned David Prouty's vote on Jim Macy's approval, telling Democrats he needed Macy reported before advancing Prouty to the Senate floor.
Sen. Sanders (I-VT) backed David Prouty but opposed Macy, Matsumoto and McDonald, while Republicans unanimously supported the three Trump nominees.
All four nominations now head to the full Senate, where confirmation would restore the NLRB quorum and install new BLS and NEH leadership.
Transcript PDF
Download the full transcript as a PDF
Ready to print, read offline or share, with the summary, everyone who spoke and the video time of every paragraph.
Hearing details
View on Congress.govSenate
Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions
2h 35m
Members who spoke20
Transcript
The Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions will please come to order. Uh, we still uh need a few more people here, so I'll make my remarks, um punil- punishing the people who came early. Uh, and then we will vote on two nominees to be members of the National Labor Relations Board or the NLRB. If confirmed, Mister Jim Macy and Mister David Prouty will be charged with resolving lab- labor disputes and protecting workers' rights under federal law. This means clearing the backlog of cases caused by the Biden administration and restoring certainty for workers and the nation's economy. Mister Prouty has been confirmed once before as he served as a member of the NLRB for the past five years, and has now been re-nominated by President Trump. Mister Macy has decades of legal experience as an attorney negotiating collective bargaining agreements he'll bring a common sense and on the ground perspective to board decisions. We now have the opportunity to put workers first to maintain the board's quorum, so it works as intended. In addition to the NLRB nominees, we'll also vote on Mr. Brett, excuse me, Doctor Brett Matsumoto's nomination to be Commissioner of Labor Statistics. The current jobs report process is broken, with significant revisions undermining trust in critical BLS products that impact everyday Americans' finances. If confirmed, Mister Matsumoto will be tasked with bringing transparency, innovation and accuracy to our nation's economic data. We're also voting on Michael McDonald to be Chairman of the National Endowment for the Humanities. Mister McDonald's confirmation will allow for further preparations for the nation's quintessential implementation of policies to combat anti-semitism on college campuses and reorganization of grant funding to deserving scholars. With that, I recognize Senator Sanders.
Thank you. Um, Mister Chairman, I support David Prouty's renomination to serve on the NLRB board. And I am opposed to President Trump's three other nominees that we are considering today. We need members of the NLRB who will protect the constitutional rights of workers to form a union. The vast majority of workers in America want to form unions. They are stopped illegally time and time again. And that is the kind of, those are the kind of people we need on the NLRB who will protect workers. In my view, Mister Prouty will do just that. Unfortunately, I'm afraid that William Macy, the Republican nominee, who has spent most of his career representing the interests of management, will not. Uh, but that's not just my opinion. More importantly, it's what the AFL CIO, representing fifteen million American workers, believe. On June twenty fifth, the AFL sa- uh, CIO sent us a letter stating, quote, "We urge you to defend the NLRB's independence and workers' access to a fair day in court by maintaining its quorum with the advancement of member Prouty's nomination and declining to report Mister Macy's nomination to the senate floor i ask mr. chairman i ask unanimous consent to
ok
enter this letter this letter into the record mr. chairman i ask unanimous consent to enter this letter into the record from the afl-cio without objection mr. chairman i will also vote no on mister masamoto's nomination to serve as the commissioner uh a commissioner of the bureau of labor statistics in my view we need a bls commissioner who will give us accurate and unbiased statistics on the unemployment rate in the American workforce not someone who will tell the president what he wants to hear. Unfortunately, I do not believe Mister Matsumoto will exercise the independence necessary for this important job. Finally, I'm opposed to Mister McDonald's nomination to serve as chairman of the National Endowment for the Humanities. Mister McDonald has repeatedly signed off on using NEH funds for projects that benefit President Trump and has repeatedly signed off on using NEH funds for projects that benefit President Trump including its attempt to build trump's absurd arch in a nation's capital without congressional authorization thank you mr. chairman
seeing that the quorum is present i will now move to favorably report mr. macy's nomination the clerk shall call the roll i shall be voting yes
senator paul
aye
senator collins
aye
senator mirkowski
aye
senator marshall
aye
senator scott
aye
senator holly
aye
senator tuberville
aye
senator banks
aye
sir he's
yes
center moody
aye
sir armstrong
aye i think that proxy votes interesting
senator sanders
no
senator murray
no by proxy
senator baldwin
no by proxy
senator murphy
no by proxy
senator kane
no
senator Hassan senator hickenlooper senator markey
no
senator kim
no
senator Blunt Rochester senator also brooks
no by proxy
Senator Husted.
Come here.
Getting him here. That's why the down is on the screen.
Unless the Democrat wishes to change their vote, we are going to wait for Senator Husted. But I will also inform that the passage of Mister Macy predicates what we do with Mister Prouty. mmm hmm oh hmm um hmm What? We told the Senator Husted is in the building, I will vote for Prouty if a Democrat will flip and vote for Macy, but we're not gonna bring up Prouty unless we get Macy on there. so i don't know about the future ideas ok when the building is coming up right now uh do you have to ask the other ones right now maybe no but what we're gonna do is we're gonna go to the other yeah we'll tickle them as well about the official meeting yeah exactly town house agency yeah yeah yeah do you hear me or not for a second oh john center houston he's
chairman cassidy
aye
have twelve eyes eleven a's
ok we decide that
oh oh senator baldwin
what is the question
um
no
no ok have twelve eyes eleven a's
ok the ayes have it the nomination is agreed to and will be favorably reported to the senate we now move to mr. matzema uh doctor matzema to his voting um the clerk should call the roll i shall be voting yes
senator paul
aye
senator collins
aye
senator Murkowski senator marshall
aye
senator scott
aye
senator holly senator tuberville
aye
senator banks
aye
senator Husted
aye
senator moody senator armstrong senator sanders
no
senator murray
no but how so
senator baldwin senator murphy
no but how so
senator kane
no but how so
senator hassan senator hickenlooper senator markey senator kim senator rochester senator Alsobrooks
over at rochester
chairman cassidy
yes
aye
twelve eyes eleven nays
the ayes have it we should now move to um
ok that's a good one
mr. mcdonald um the clerk should call the roll i shall be voting yes
senator paul
aye
senator collins murkowski senator murkowski
aye
senator Marshall
aye
senator scott
aye
senator Hawley
aye
senator Tuberville
aye
senator banks
aye
senator Husted
aye
senator moody
aye
senator armstrong
aye
senator sanders
more than six minutes
senator murray
don't by proxy
senator baldwin
no
mmm
senator murphy
don't by proxy
senator Kaine
no
senator hassan
no
senator hickenlooper senator markey
oh
senator kim
no no
senator rochester
yes
senator alcer brooks
don't by proxy
chairman cassidy
aye
we have twelve eyes eleven ears
those eyes have it we should now move to mr.
proudy uh the culture call the roll senator paul
yeah
senator collins
aye
senator Murkowski senator marshall
aye
senator scott
no
senator holly
aye
senator tuberville
no
senator banks
no
senator Husted
aye
senator moody
no
senator armstrong
aye
holly was first senator sanders
aye
so they there we go senator murray
no way don't pass
senator baldwin center murphy
i by bert
senator Kaine
aye
senator Hassan
aye
senator hickenlooper
aye
senator markey senator kim
aye
senator Blunt Rochester senator Alsobrooks
i by bert rochester
chairman cassidy
no
have seventeen eyes six nays
the eyes have it the nomination is agreed to and is favorably reported to the senate um thank you
you're welcome
the committee stands adjourned
Morning digest
Start every morning briefed on yesterday’s hearings
A free weekday email covering yesterday’s hearings and transcripts newly unlocked in the archive.



